New York Judge John Hunt rails against disparate treatment of boys by probation department

May 29, 2012
By

boysBelow is one example of gender bias in the criminal justice system.  The bias is so pervasive that the story is about a single judge who decided to rebel against it.

 All of these things have consequences.  The boy who is treated more harshly than the girl gets a criminal record that reduces his likelihood of finishing high school, his prospects for getting into college, his opportunities for employment, and on and on to the grave.

 If the boy and girl are arrested a second time, the disparity in treatment becomes still wider because he is a “repeat offender” while her record was purged of the first offense.

 Add to this the gender bias in disciplinary matters inside schools and I am convinced that a large portion of the “male academic underachievement” is explained by disparate treatment of males and females in disciplinary matters.

 There is a significant effort to reduce over-criminalization of minority males but the bias is also gender driven, not just race driven, so programs that only address race are only addressing a part of the problem.

 Judged bashes Probation Department for gender bias in favor of leniency for girls

By Simone Weichselbaum and Thomas Zambito, DAILY NEWS STAFF WRITERS

A Queens judge is blasting the city’s Probation Department for going easier on teenage girls than boys – even when they commit the same crimes.

Family Court Judge John Hunt accused probation of gender bias for trying to spare all but the most violent girls from prison time and the scarlet letter of the juvenile delinquent.

Hunt analyzed the cases of eight teenagers who had come before him – four boys and four girls – and found that probation routinely recommended tougher treatment for boys.

Take Queens eighth-graders Stephen C. and Jennifer S.

The teens took part in the robbery of a boy who was punched, kicked and choked before having his iPod wrested away. Probation recommended that Stephen be put on supervised probation while Jennifer should have her case eventually dismissed.

Judge Hunt disagreed Monday and ordered both teens put on probation for 18 months.

“The court could find no cogent reason why Jennifer S. should be treated differently than her accomplice, Stephen C.,” Hunt wrote.

Hunt blamed a “seemingly bizarre, sterile and largely impersonal system” for the disparate treatment.

In an effort to trim the number of locked-up juveniles, the city partnered with the Vera Institute of Justice in 2003 to develop a computer-generated program that would take the guesswork out of probation officers’ recommendations.

A higher score on the Probation Assessment Tool (PAT) means a recommendation that could lead to eventual dismissal of charges. A lower score means probation or lockup, not to mention the juvenile delinquent tag.

Hunt claims PAT routinely rewards girls with 14 extra points for gender alone, while boys get 0.

“The system contains a built-in gender bias in favor of female delinquents,” Hunt writes.

Probation officials say the computer tool predicts the likelihood of a juvenile being rearrested based on a study of 763 similar cases.

“It is an assessment tool,” said Ryan Dodge, a probation spokesman. “The court can always go against it. It is not set in stone.”

Hunt said probation offered up no statistics to suggest boys were more likely to get in trouble again.

Thank you Judge Hunt! We know what you did took a great deal of courage. You too Mr. Weichselbaum and Mr. Zambito!

http://ncfm.org/contact-elected-representatives/

 

boys boys boys boys boys boys boys boys boys boys boys boys

boys boys boys boys boys boys boys boys boys boys boys boys boys boys boys boys

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Facebook
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Google Buzz
  • LinkedIn
  • Orkut
  • Twitter

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

2 Responses to New York Judge John Hunt rails against disparate treatment of boys by probation department

  1. BarbieLyn on June 7, 2012 at 12:49 PM

    WHY IS THERE SO MUCH GENDER RACISM AGAINST MEN IN AMERICA????

  2. Marcos_FA on June 6, 2012 at 8:23 PM

    I wanna live in the same city this judge lives :)

Leave a Reply

See NCFM Wayback

waybackmachineOver the years millions of people worldwide have visited a National Coalition For Men website. Also over the years the site has changed dramatically, been taken down, moved, and otherwise uprooted. In those processes much information was lost, not recovered, and does not appear on this site. However you can see earlier versions and many of the extraordinary accomplishments of NCFM back to 1996 by using the WayBackMachine. In the search box type www.ncfm.org

Attend if you can!!

national coalition for men

Are Things Really Equal?

Girlwriteswhat on ideological feminism and its impact on our society and culture

campus hate speech

More on the war against males in education

Bookmark this site if you are a college student or parent who cares about the children regardless of their age…

a voice for male students

sexual harassment on campus

sexual harassment DOE

This explains why our politicians do stupid things about domestic violence

Interview with Erin Pizzey, the women who started the domestic violence shelter movement

Click on the picture below for Erin’s website

Other MUST WATCH Videos

 

realsexism.com

sexism

Great Resources for Abused Men

 
  • Dometic Abuse Hotline for Men and Women, based in Maine, offers 24-hour hotline: 1-888-7HELPLINE (1-888-743-5754) and may be offering shelter services.
  • Valley Oasis in Lancater, CA has offers shelter and other services for men and their children. 24-hour Hotline: (661) 945-6736.
  • Family of Men Support Society, Calgary, Canada, shelter and support services.
  • Male Survivor, Overcoming Sexual Victimization of Boys and Men
  • probono.net, provides resources for pro bono and legal services attorneys and others working to assist low income or disadvantaged clients.
  • LawHelp.org, helps low and moderate income people find free legal aid programs in their communities, answers to questions about their legal rights, and find forms to help with their legal problems.
  • Shared Parenting Works has parenting plans and other resources.
  • Walk a Mile in HIS Shoes resources for abused men in Canada.
  • One in Three Campaign resoures for abused men in Australia.
  • Stop Abuse for Everyone, one of the most comprehensive and oldest sites dedicated to victims of domestic violence. The site was recently upgraded with the assistance of NCFM. The site includes an interactive map of north America for helping to find shelter services that might or do help abused men.

More great resources for men and those who care about men. Ask your elected officials if they do.

Men's Health Network

%d bloggers like this: