Call Email Join Donate
Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

NCFM in the News, Telegraph UK, Is it time for a #HeToo movement? Meet the US men fighting for male rights?

August 6, 2018
By
national coalition for men

#HeToo: Harry Crouch the president of The National Coalition for Menย CREDIT:ย COLEMAN-RAYNER

Harry Crouchโ€™s San Diego office is a study in male outrage. The shelves are stacked with books entitledย Making Monsters: False Memories,ย Psychotherapy and Sexual Hysteria,ย Legalising Misandryย andย Hotsy Totsy FemiNazi, badges – โ€œCalifornia is Sexist & Hateful Against Menโ€ โ€“ adorn the walls, and a bumper sticker on the back of the door reads: โ€œDonโ€™t be THAT girl: embarrassed about a hook-up? Angry at a boyfriend? Willing to destroy a life?โ€

Then, in the midst of it all, a jarringly tender mug: โ€˜FATHER: all that you are has been a major force in my lifeโ€™. Because the President of the National Coalition For Men (NCFM) is a husband, a father, and a grandfather.

And his #HeToo crusade to โ€œeradicate gender-based stereotypesโ€ andย fight for male civil rightsย in world he considers increasingly sexist and hateful towards men is for those two grandsons. He says, โ€œI canโ€™t imagine what those boys are going to be confronted by in a few years unless we take action.โ€

Right now, as part of a concerted push-back against 10 months of#MeToo, NCFM members are taking plenty of action โ€“ the legal kind โ€“ and making both news and history with a series of lawsuits theyโ€™re slapping on Ladies’ Night style gatherings โ€“ almost all of them successful.

There’s been a pushback. Now when a woman comes forward and accuses [a man of sexual assault], I think people are beginning to ask: โ€˜Reallyโ€ฆ?โ€™

As the โ€œoldest menโ€™s rights organisation on the planet,โ€ they have been acting on issues from domestic violence and equal parenting rights; to trying to prevent the men falsely accused of sexual assault from becoming โ€œsacrificial scapegoats to satisfy some feminist or political agendaโ€, for years. But this feels like the start of a more robust fight.

Put this to Crouch โ€“ a curmudgeonly 68 year-old who becomes warmer and less guarded over our time together โ€“ and he frowns. As catchy as it sounds, the NCFM hasnโ€™t yet embraced the #HeToo brand people are keen to impose on it.

โ€œThere has been this bias against males for decades,โ€ explains the man who wears four black and blue โ€œSave The Malesโ€ wristbands at any one time, handing them out in lieu of business cards.

#MeToo

Ashley Judd, Annabella Sciorra and Salma Hayek on stage at the 2018 Academy Awards to pay tribute to the #MeToo and #TimesUp movementsย CREDIT:ย CRAIG SJODINย /DISNEY ABC TELEVISION GROUP

โ€œBut most people just havenโ€™t seen it until recently, when everything that has gone onย has made them more aware. And you know โ€˜theyโ€™ are starting to panic a bit because weโ€™re gaining purchase,โ€ he adds obliquely โ€“ before clarifying that any โ€˜theysโ€™ peppering his conversation refer to โ€œthe oppositionโ€, and not necessarily a uniquely female one at that.

โ€œThe idea that I hate all women is ridiculous and stupid,โ€ he groans. โ€œWe are an inclusive organisation who employ a number of women, too. But while the opposition run on emotion, we run on facts. Youโ€™d think most people with an IQ of over 60 could understand the basic concepts of fairness and equality, wouldnโ€™t you? And yet itโ€™s amazing how many academics struggle with them.โ€

Perhaps because intellectual arguments would get them nowhere, the NCFM have been using the legal system to make a larger point, and successfully suing a number of businesses and organisations offering either women-only gatherings or discounts to women.

#MeToo

A noticeboard in the National Coalition for Men headquarters in San Diego, Californiaย CREDIT:COLEMAN-RAYNER

One of the key players at the NCFM, Rich Allison โ€“ a former Marine Corps captain who has been a plaintiff in 13 lawsuits โ€“ has been waging war against organisations like the Financial Services Information Sharing and Analysis Center, who were offering a โ€œdiversity scholarshipโ€ to female recipients, and Ladies’ Get Paid: a career development company for women who had the temerity to turn him away from one of their gatherings in a San Diego bar.

โ€œI believe in social justice and fairness,โ€ says Allison, who cites the day he saw a 2015 Superbowl T-Mobile advert, in which comedian Sarah Silverman hands a couple their newborn baby and says โ€œSorry, itโ€™s a boy,โ€ as his tipping point.

โ€œTheyโ€™d never allow that ad with a girl,โ€ he says. True. But isnโ€™t it a sad world when Ladies’ Night has to be banned? And I say that as someone who personally canโ€™t think of anything worse.

ย  ย  ย  ย  ย  ย  ย  ย  ย  ย  ย  ย  ย  ย  ย  ย  ย  ย  ย  ย  ย 

โ€œWell, California eliminated all menโ€™s clubs a while ago,โ€ Allison points out. โ€œAnd I do think that what weโ€™re doing is effective. The suits are getting people to focus.โ€

Behind almost all these lawsuits is local lawyer, Alfred G. Rava. Formerly NCFMโ€™s secretary, he has filed some 300 cases in total โ€“ a rate of about one a month for the past three years. His first Unruh Civil Rights Act sex discrimination lawsuit was the result of a night out in 2002, when Rava was required to pay a $10 admissionย fee to enter a local bar where women were allowed in free.

Rava went home, found out that Ladies’ Nights had been illegal in California since at least 1985, and proceeded to sue –ย beginning almost all of his sexual discrimination suits with the Animal Farm quote: โ€œAll animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.โ€

The legal way isnโ€™t necessarily the best or indeed the only way to fight for menโ€™s rights, insists Crouch, โ€œbut itโ€™s certainly true that we can affect change more rapidly through litigation than through legislation.โ€

Isnโ€™t it a sad world when Ladies’ Night has to be banned? And I say that as someone who personally canโ€™t think of anything worse

The NCFM President โ€“ who was once in a relationship โ€œwith a woman who would get violentโ€ โ€“ says this as someone who has tried to work with the state on projects like setting up a programme for abused men. โ€œI was told โ€“ and this is a direct quote: โ€˜It will be a cold day in hell before our commission or any other agency gives you a dollar for abused menโ€™,” he adds.

Unlike #MeToo, male celebrities are not rushing to give the NCFM injections of cash, laughs Crouch. โ€œAlthough there does seem to be a push back going on. Which is not to say in any shape or form that #MeToo hasnโ€™t had so much legitimacy, because it absolutely does. But unfortunately it has also brought more attention to false allegations. And false allegations hurt everybody: men and women. We need to be talking about that more.โ€

It does seem like companies are not overly inclined to fight for their male employees. โ€œTheyโ€™re just rolling over, panicked that their stock prices are going to take a dive – as though it doesnโ€™t matter where the truth lies. But now when a woman comes forward and accuses someone of status, I think people are beginning to ask: โ€˜Really?โ€™โ€

#HeToo

Harry Crouch in the NCFM’s San Diego HQย CREDIT:ย COLEMAN-RAYNERย ย 

Harvey Weinsteinย being outed as a Hollywood-style villain hasnโ€™t been helpful, agrees Crouch, โ€œbecause heโ€™s not representative of a normal man in so many ways, from his apparent talent and his wealth to the appalling way he treated women.

“If all thoseย accusationsย are true –ย which I doubt by the way –ย then he is absolutely horrific. But we never talk about the women who position themselves around people like that with the hope of exploiting them in order to obtain career advancement. We also never talk about the women who jump into bed with a man for that same reason, and then turn around and blame them for something.โ€

Crouch isnโ€™t entirely right in that respect: after all here we are, talking about just that. And writer Philip W. Cook โ€“ who has spent years researching and writing about men who have been sexually abused, stalked, controlled and coerced by women โ€“ believes the conversations weโ€™re having now will eventually lead to a greater understanding between the sexes.

We never talk about the women who position themselves around men with the hope of career advancement

โ€œItโ€™s going to take a long time for these kinds of non-gender biased facts to reach public or media consciousness,โ€ the author ofย Abused Men: The Hidden Side of Domestic Violence, tells me. โ€œBut attitudes can change. Both men and women engage in sexually coercive tactics, the styles may vary but the substance does not.โ€

Crouch needs to go and prepare for a conference in South Carolina where he will represent the NCFM โ€“ and hand out those wristbands. But Iโ€™m curious to know whether he too feels that there will be a correction, in time.

โ€œI hope that the people who grew up with loving men and have a voice will speak out more.โ€ He pauses for a moment.

โ€œThere is a sociological phenomenon called dynamic equilibrium where you swing back and forth before getting to the middle, and I do think that things are coming down a little bit now. But that pendulum is not coming back to the centre in my lifetime.โ€

Maybe not. Though of course where that centre lies depends very much on where you stand in the first place.

national coalition for men

Is it time for aย #HeToo movement? Meet the US men fighting for male rights?

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.