The OCR’s Newest Target: Xavier University

August 3, 2012

due processNCFM note: more challenges to protecting due process on college campuses… and elsewhere. If you would like to help us establish NCFM chapters on college campuses please contact us.

In his 1946 linguistic critique, Politics and the English Language, George Orwell wrote that one must “let meaning choose the word, not the other way around.” By largely ignoring this truism, administrators and legislators who craft imprecise regulations have given their particular enforcement arms—campus disciplinary staff and federal government prosecutors—enormous and grotesquely unfair power.  — Harvey A. Silverglate, author of Three Felonies a Day, How the Feds Target the Innocent


Posted by KC Johnson, in Minding Our Campuses Reforming Our Universities

The Cincinnati Enquirer reports that Education Department’s Office of Civil Rights (OCR) has entered into its latest Title IX-related agreement with Xavier University. Unlike the OCR’s agreement with Yale, which used a manufactured controversy to weaken the due process rights of the university’s students, at least at Xavier the OCR involved itself only in response to actual complaints of sexual assault. But, as with Yale, the outcome revealed a basic lack of respect for the presumption of innocence and fair play for all students.

The heart of the case at Xavier, according to the Enquirer: “Two female Xavier students charged that a male student was twice allowed to remain on campus after being found responsible for sexual assaults, and a third charged that XU did not treat her fairly in her sexual harassment and stalking claim.”

In fact, the male student, Sean Marron, was acquitted of four counts of sexual assault in a bench trial. The trial records were sealed, but according to the court reporter, the judge ruled as he did “due to inconsistencies” in the accusers’ stories and “a lack of evidence.” In the aftermath, Xavier dismissed two student life officials, on grounds that they mishandled the female students’ on-campus complaints, before the students filed criminal complaints against Marron.

Some portions of the OCR-Xavier agreement are unobjectionable. For instance, the agreement requires Xavier to conduct “impartial” investigations of sexual assault complaints, to include “the opportunity for the parties to present witnesses and evidence.” How this requirement is consistent with the OCR’s Yale agreement (which helped to usher in the “informal complaint” procedure in which accused students don’t have a right to present evidence of their innocence) the OCR doesn’t say. Indeed, another provision of the agreement urges Xavier not to use the “informal” complaint procedure that Yale has made notorious. (The female students claimed that the dismissed Xavier administrators tried to use the mediation process to make their claims go away.)

If, in fact, the OCR were actually committed to “impartial” investigations of on-campus sexual assault, or eager to ensure a full presentation of evidence in disciplinary proceedings, the Xavier letter might be admirable. But, of course, fairness is not OCR head Russlynn Ali’s goal, as other components of the Xavier letter make clear.

First, unsurprisingly, is a lack of concern with traditional standards of due process that had become one of Ali’s hallmarks. At the OCR’s demand, the Xavier agreement institutionalizes double jeopardy, giving accusers the right to appeal any not-guilty finding. And the agreement requires training of all Xavier officials in the “appropriate legal standards” to follow in campus sexual assault complaints. Lest there be any doubt: in the OCR’s “preponderance-of-evidence” world, these standards “differ from a criminal investigation.”

Second, the agreement praises Xavier for establishing a “Title IX Task Force” consisting of “groups focused on prevention of sexual assault already on campus.” This task force doesn’t include any civil libertarian organizations, or legal clinic groups. But it does include the Office of Multicultural Affairs. The OCR’s apparent message: far-left campus organizations are perfectly acceptable to assist in setting up campus sexual assault policy. (Needless to say, no right-of-center groups were assigned to Xavier’s Title IX Task Force.)

Third, in a discussion of sexual assault complaints, the OCR demands “assurance that victims are aware of their Title IX rights.” But, of course, at the stage of the complaint, the accuser is at most an alleged victim. By deeming the accuser a “victim,” is the OCR accepting the argument of extremists such as Wendy Murphy that women never lie about rape? Or does the OCR believe that even women who file false claims of sexual harassment or assault are nonetheless, somehow, “victims”?

Finally, the OCR makes clear its contempt for the judge’s ruling in the Marron case. Under the terms of the agreement, if Marron returns to Xavier (he’s currently enrolled at another school in Ohio), Xavier must explore prohibiting Marron’s enrollment in the same “same courses, academic activities, and extracurricular activities” in which one of the accusers–or, in the OCR’s language, one of the “victims”–is enrolled. Again, a judge found Marron not guilty because of inconsistencies and a lack of evidence in the accuser’s tale.

An acquittal, it seems, must not be allowed to come in the way of the OCR’s agenda.

 More about discrimination against men in education.

due process

due process

due process

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Facebook
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Google Buzz
  • LinkedIn
  • Orkut
  • Twitter

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

One Response to The OCR’s Newest Target: Xavier University

  1. Ray on August 12, 2012 at 6:16 PM

    This male bashing/male witch-hunting, left wing agenda is present in the classrooms, and halls, and grounds on college and university campuses all across America. Rape witch-hunting is just one aspect aspect of the witch-hunting of males that goes on as shown in “Witch-hunting Males” at Youtube. A lot of male witch-hunting that goes on in society originates in these misandrist, collegiate spawning grounds.

    But there’s a larger agenda that this is all a part of, as any student who’s not deaf, dumb, and blind can see. “Witch-Hunting Males” is only a part of the larger Feminist, Marxist-Leninist propaganda that’s pervasive in academia as shown in Marxist Valley College at Youtube. And “yes” special bogey MEN and straw MEN are routinely set up and villified by this feminist agenda so pardon me if I merely point out their very active overt ties and prejudices. Why point out the bigger picture? Because the misandry and male witch-hunting rarely takes place outside the larger Marxist-Leninist feminist agenda present in academia, rather it is an integral part of it. Any male, or female, who’s ever questioned, or stood up against, the on-campus misandry has likely experienced the bigoted reaction of being labeled a “right wing extremist,” even though he/she has no ties whatsoever to the right.

Leave a Reply

national coalition for men
donate now blue

See NCFM Wayback

waybackmachineOver the years millions of people worldwide have visited a National Coalition For Men website. Also over the years the site has changed dramatically, been taken down, moved, and otherwise uprooted. In those processes much information was lost, not recovered, and does not appear on this site. However you can see earlier versions and many of the extraordinary accomplishments of NCFM back to 1996 by using the WayBackMachine. In the search box type

Are Things Really Equal?




“The Red Pill” documentary extended sneak preview

Save Our Heroes

Honorable Men

The New Warrior community is a group of men who specially pride themselves on being honorable. Tim Goldich, President NCFM Chicago Chapter and author of, Loving Men, Respecting Women: The Future of Gender Politics joined that community several years ago. He came to realize just how vulnerable honorable men are to having their honor used against them. Our fate may indeed depend upon honorable conduct. To better understand how the misuse of Man’s honor is a root cause of issues and ideas found on this website you should first read Mr. Goldich’s article, The Honorable Man. It lights the way to understanding how The Honorable Man can be manipulated into becoming The Complacent Man.

Rape Hysteria by Students, Part 3 – Misandry in Education

From Women’s Rights to Feminist Wrongs: Society’s Contemporary Contempt for Men

Men’s Issues

Military corruption

NCFM Adviser Philip W. Cook with “Girl Writes What” NCFM Member Karen Straughan

Girlwriteswhat on ideological feminism and its impact on our society and culture

Campus Hate Speech: Warren Farrell protest at University of Toronto

Foundation for Male Studies Conference: Looking Forward to Solutions Part 1

Foundation for Male Studies Conference: Looking Forward to Solutions Part 2

Please donate to the Foundation for Male Studies. There may be nothing more important for our future than to assure the fair, equitable, and high quality education of our boys and men.

More on the war against males in education

Great site for facts and relevant articles

center for prosecutorial integrety


Erin Pizzey’s website

More MUST WATCH Videos

Male Victims of Domestic Violence – The Hidden Story

Dr. Helen

Protect yourself! Get the book!

Great Resources for Abused Men

  • Valley Oasis in Lancater, CA offers shelter and other services for men, women, and their children. 24-hour Hotline: (661) 945-6736.
  • Male Survivor, Overcoming Sexual Victimization of Boys and Men
  •, provides resources for pro bono and legal services attorneys and others working to assist low income or disadvantaged clients.
  •, helps low and moderate income people find free legal aid programs in their communities, answers to questions about their legal rights, and find forms to help with their legal problems.
  • Shared Parenting Works has parenting plans and other resources.
  • One in Three Campaign resoures for abused men in Australia.
  • Stop Abuse for Everyone, one of the most comprehensive and oldest sites dedicated to victims of domestic violence. The site was recently upgraded with the assistance of NCFM. The site includes an interactive map of north America for helping find shelter services that might or do help abused men.


%d bloggers like this: